Home / Solutions / Internal audit

Role

ProcureAudit for Internal Audit | Sampling Procurement
Sample the population. The support comes with it.

The slowest part of a purchasing audit is rarely the analysis. It is getting hold of the records, which usually means asking the team you are reviewing to find them for you.

Evidence exports with the sampleActivity entries are append only
What actually slows an audit

Getting hold of the records

Analysis is quick. Collection is slow, and asking the team under review to assemble their own evidence is both slow and methodologically uncomfortable.

Internal audit • Walkthrough

Getting hold of the records

Analysis is quick. Collection is slow, and asking the team under review to assemble their own evidence is both slow and methodologically uncomfortable.

  • You get the records without asking
  • The activity record carries weight
  • Exceptions are already identified
ProcureAudit You get the records without asking
Outcome 01

You get the records without asking

Filtering the population and exporting the sample with evidence attached removes the collection step and the dependency on the team being reviewed.

What that meansFieldwork that starts immediately rather than after a fortnight of requests.
ProcureAudit The activity record carries weight
Outcome 02

The activity record carries weight

Entries written as work happens and not editable afterwards are evidence. A log that could have been tidied up later is not, and everybody knows it.

What that meansFindings resting on records rather than on assurances about records.
ProcureAudit Exceptions are already identified
Outcome 03

Exceptions are already identified

Because exceptions were recorded as exceptions at the time with reasons attached, the interesting population is available rather than something you have to derive.

What that meansTesting concentrated where it is worth concentrating.
Traditional fieldwork against this approach

Where purchasing audits lose time

Every one of these is about access to records rather than about the testing itself.

Book a demo
ProcureAudit Requesting it
The challenge

Requesting it

You define the population, ask the team to supply the records, and wait. What arrives is what they could find, which is not necessarily what exists.

MethodRequest
DelayDays or weeks
CompletenessUncertain
ProcureAudit Filtering it yourself
With ProcureAudit

Filtering it yourself

The population is filterable directly and the sample exports with supporting documents attached to each record.

MethodFilter
DelayNone
CompletenessKnown
ProcureAudit Chased per item
The challenge

Chased per item

Each sampled item generates follow up requests for the document behind it, and the round trips are where audits lose weeks.

ArrivesPer request
Round tripsMany
EffortBoth sides
ProcureAudit Attached to the record
With ProcureAudit

Attached to the record

The evidence sits against the award, modification and phase, so it exports with the sample rather than being requested afterwards.

ArrivesWith the sample
Round tripsFew
EffortMinimal
ProcureAudit Potentially editable
The challenge

Potentially editable

A log that can be adjusted after the fact is difficult to rely on, regardless of whether it was actually adjusted.

EditableOften
WeightLimited
TestingExtra
ProcureAudit Append only
With ProcureAudit

Append only

Entries are written as work happens and cannot be changed afterwards, which is what allows the sequence to be relied on.

EditableNo
WeightFull
TestingLess
ProcureAudit Derived by analysis
The challenge

Derived by analysis

Identifying which transactions deviated means analysing the whole population, because exceptions were never marked as such.

IdentifiedBy analysis
EffortHigh
ConfidenceModerate
ProcureAudit Already marked
With ProcureAudit

Already marked

Exceptions were recorded as exceptions at the time with reasons, so the population exists rather than needing derivation.

IdentifiedAt the time
EffortNone
ConfidenceHigh
Through fieldwork

Where a purchasing audit loses its time

Internal audit • Walkthrough

Where a purchasing audit loses its time

Filtered directly by value, period or type rather than requested from the team.

  • Defining the population
  • Pulling the sample
  • Testing approvals
01
Filtered byValue, period, type
Requested from teamNo
DelayNone

Defining the population

Filtered directly by value, period or type rather than requested from the team.

Learn more
02
SupportAttached
Round tripsFew
CompletenessKnown

Pulling the sample

Exported with supporting documents attached rather than chased item by item.

Learn more
03
ApproverNamed
Version approvedRecorded
LocationThe record

Testing approvals

Approver, timestamp and approved version all on the record rather than in an inbox.

Learn more
04
IdentifiedAt the time
ReasonRecorded
Derivation neededNone

Reviewing exceptions

Already identified as exceptions with reasons recorded at the time.

Learn more
05
Rule locationThe template
Fires onAward value
JudgementNot involved

Testing a threshold

The rule sits in the template, so testing checks the rule and its exceptions rather than every award.

Learn more
06
AttributionEvery action
Editable afterNo
SequenceProvable

Tracing who did what

Every entry named and timed, written as work happened and not editable afterwards.

Learn more
What comes with a sample

Six things attached to each record

ProcureAudit The award record
01

The award record

Value, type, supplier and dates, without a separate request.

ProcureAudit The reasoning
02

The reasoning

Why the award went where it did, written at the decision.

ProcureAudit The approvals
03

The approvals

Who approved, when, and against which version of the document.

ProcureAudit The evidence
04

The evidence

Documents filed against the phase they support, exported alongside.

ProcureAudit The activity trail
05

The activity trail

Every action with a name and a timestamp, not editable afterwards.

ProcureAudit The modifications
06

The modifications

Each with its own amounts and approvals rather than blended into the parent.

FAQ

Questions from internal audit

Can I pull a sample without involving the team?
Yes, and that is usually the main change. The population is filterable directly and the sample exports with supporting documents attached, so fieldwork does not begin with a request.
Does the supporting evidence come with the sample?
Yes. Documents sit against the award, modification and phase, so they export alongside rather than generating follow up requests item by item.
Can activity entries be edited after the fact?
No. Entries are written as work happens and left alone, which is what allows the sequence to carry weight rather than requiring separate testing.
How are exceptions identified?
They were recorded as exceptions at the time with reasons attached, so the population exists rather than having to be derived by analysing everything.
Can I test whether thresholds were applied?
Yes. Thresholds fire on award value from the template, so testing is a matter of checking the rule and the exceptions rather than examining every transaction.
What about awards from before implementation?
Historic records can be loaded, but evidence that was never captured cannot be recovered. That limitation is worth stating in scope rather than discovering during fieldwork.
Does this replace our audit software?
No. It is the source of the purchasing records and evidence. Workpapers, testing and reporting stay wherever you manage them.
More solutions

Other sectors and roles worth reading

ProcureAudit Compliance officers
SOLUTION

Compliance officers

Checking a team you cannot watch transaction by transaction.

Learn more
ProcureAudit Contracts managers
SOLUTION

Contracts managers

The person who has to produce the file, usually at short notice.

Learn more
ProcureAudit Subcontract administrators
SOLUTION

Subcontract administrators

Modification records and supplier documents kept current across a program.

Learn more

Bring a scope you are planning

We will show what filtering the population and exporting the sample would look like against live records.

Book a demo